Unsupported Browser

ESL Library's search may not function properly in Internet Explorer. We recommend using Google Chrome or Firefox instead.

Unsupported Browser

ESL Library's search may not function properly in older browsers. We recommend updating yours to the latest version for the best experience.

Search ESL Libraryfor lessons, resources, flashcards, or blog posts

Sorry, we couldn’t find any lessons, resources, flashcards, or blog posts matching that search term.

Unsupported Browser

ESL Library may not function properly in Internet Explorer. We recommend using Google Chrome or Firefox instead.

Unsupported Browser

ESL Library may not function properly in older browsers. We recommend updating yours to the latest version for the best experience.

Restrictive & Non-Restrictive Adjective Clauses

by | May 8, 2014

Tanya grammar banner

Can adjective clauses, which can be confusing for students, ever be easily learned?

As if adjective clauses (also called relative clauses) weren't complicated enough already, our students also need to learn when to add punctuation. In my experience, some textbooks deal with the punctuation issue much later on (or not at all) in an adjective clause lesson. I prefer to explain it to my students fairly early on before they start practicing doing the wrong thing.

The following are some teaching tips on the punctuation of restrictive and non-restrictive adjective clauses. (And does anyone else get the terms restrictive and non‑restrictive mixed up? I always had to double-check before class!)

Restrictive Adjective Clauses

Restrictive / Defining Adjective Clauses
  • Follow a GENERAL noun
  • Don't use commas!

Restrictive adjective clauses (also known as defining adjective clauses) contain information that is necessary to define the noun. The noun is a general noun such as boy, apple, book, city, etc. A good tip to tell your students is that if the meaning is any, then it's a general noun (book = any book; I don't have a specific book in mind).

Because the noun is general, it needs information to specify/define it so that we know which noun the speaker is talking about. The adjective clause, then, is important information that defines the noun, and because it is important, no commas are needed. (Remind students that commas are often used to offset secondary, less important information in English.)

Point out that even though the noun is general, the adjective clause is going to define the noun, so we usually need the article the, not a, with adjective clauses that are defining a subject noun. For an object noun, either article is possible.

Examples

  • The boy who is running around the room is my son.
  • I met the boy who was running around the room.
  • The woman who is wearing the red dress told me the time.
  • The apple that I had at lunch was delicious.
  • The book that I finished reading yesterday was really interesting.
  • I finished reading a book that was really interesting.
  • The city that I want to visit the most is Paris.

Non-Restrictive Adjective Clauses

Non-Restrictive / Non-Defining Adjective Clauses
  • Follow a SPECIFIC noun
  • Use commas!

Non-restrictive adjective clauses (also known as non-defining adjective clauses) contain information that is NOT necessary to define the noun (it is simply extra info). The noun is a specific noun such as the proper name of a person, place, or thing, or a noun already defined by a pronoun/adjective/attributive noun, etc. A good tip to tell your students is that if it's clear which noun the speaker is talking about, then it's a specific noun (Paris = a specific city; I know which city it is).

Because the noun is specific, it DOESN'T need information to specify/define it because we already know which noun the speaker is talking about. The adjective clause, then, is extra information that doesn't define the noun, so commas are needed. (Remind students that commas are often used to offset secondary, less important information in English.)

Examples

  • My son, who is running around the room, had too much sugar earlier.
  • I scolded my son, who was misbehaving in front of my guests.
  • Mr. Jones, who is my teacher, has been at this school for 25 years.
  • My lunch, which I ate in five minutes, was delicious.
  • The Hobbit, which was an excellent book, was made into a movie.
  • I finished reading the Hobbit, which was made into a movie.
  • Paris, which I visited last year, has a lot of interesting architecture.

Note: Be aware that some textbooks don't use the hyphen (they use nonrestrictive)—stick with the word/spelling used in your students' main textbook.

Related Practice

Final Note

I plan on writing another blog post or two about which pronouns to use with restrictive/non-restrictive adjective clauses, but I'll mention one case here because it involves punctuation. Many people follow this rule:

Use that for restrictive adjective clauses and which for non-restrictive adjective clauses. (I.e., use that when there's no comma and which following a comma.)

Examples

  • The book that I finished reading was great.
  • My science textbook, which was boring, took me a long time to read.

Note that these rules are very common in American and Canadian English. In the UK, "which" is still accepted in both types of clauses, according to the New Oxford Style Manual. What about other English-speaking countries? My colleague from New Zealand said that they use "that" in restrictive clauses, not "which." I'd love to hear from other people in the comments section below!

Not an ESL Library member?

Get unlimited access to 1,000+ lessons and 3,000+ flashcards.

Sign Up

Comments (9)

Avatar default

blair (Guest)

what's the different between which and that?

Reply to Comment
Team tanya

Tanya Trusler(Author)

Hi Blair,

In restrictive clauses, 'which' and 'that' are both pronouns that replace a 'thing' (i.e., they have the same meaning). The difference is that in American and Canadian English, 'that' is used in restrictive clauses (without commas) and 'which' is used in restrictive clauses (with commas). In British English, 'which' is used in both types of clauses. In fact, even in North America, 'which' can be used in restrictive clauses, but note that it sounds a lot more formal to use it that way and some people will argue that it's incorrect.

Thumbnail koala02

Rodolfo F.(Teacher)

Hello, Tanya
I'm sorry I'm late to the party, but I have a few question regarding the way you describe the use of WHICH. I mean, from what I've heard, I was told that THAT is the relative pronoun that restricts, which is why it never comes followed by a comma, whereas WHICH only adds non-restrictive information to the sentence, which is why it's considered non-restrictive.
Could you please confirm such information or suggest a fix? Thanks.

Reply to Comment
Team tanya

Tanya Trusler(Author)

Hi Rodolfo,

You are correct! We use 'that' for important (restrictive) information, and we don't use commas. We use 'which' for less important, extra information (unrestrictive), and we use commas.

Just be careful to follow the rules based on where you're teaching or studying. This is how we do it in North America, but in British English, I believe 'which' is commonly used for both cases (with no commas for restrictive clauses, and commas for unrestrictive clauses, as usual).

Avatar default

peter (Guest)

Good teaching ! God bless you!!

Reply to Comment
Team tanya

Tanya Trusler(Author)

Thank you, Peter!

Team tanya

Tanya Trusler(Author)

Mark Sherman wrote:
"Much to the dismay of those of us who were raised on different rules, WHICH is now acceptable in restrictive clauses in the United States -- "I love the book which was published last week," for example. Or: "I just read a story which says the president is giving a speech tonight." One day, we'll all die off, and no one will have any qualms about it; until then, such usage seems to mark, in its own small way, the decline of Western civilization ..."

Hi, Mark!

We've just turned off comments on our old blog, and we've just made this post live on our new blog so I can answer you. Sorry for any confusion!

Thank you for your comment! I know what you mean—with the advent of social media and texting, I see usage becoming more casual all the time and the old "rules" are dropping like flies. The evolution of language is always fascinating, but it sure makes it tough for English teachers to decide what to teach our students! I remember many a time where I'd teach my student a grammar rule only to have them come back the next day and say, "But teacher, I saw it another way yesterday. Why?" These types of changes are great discussion topics for high-level learners, but they sure can confuse the heck out of low-level students!

Reply to Comment
Thumbnail bear02

John W.(Teacher)

I agree the terminology isn’t great. I like to think of restrictive vs non-restrictive as identifying vs informing, since the former enables the hearer to identify the thing (or things) being talked about, while the latter simply adds information.

About the article that goes with the subject noun: even though ‘the’ occurs much more commonly, I’m not sure that should be stated as a rule. I’m new to ESL, but if I understand restrictive adjective clauses correctly, the following are counterexamples, aren’t they?:
— A song that has explicit lyrics is not appropriate for the classroom.
— Any customer that wants to pay cash can line up over here.
— Whatever happens in Vegas stays in Vegas

Reply to Comment
Team tanya

Tanya Trusler(Author)

Hi John,

The terms identifying and informing make a lot of sense! They would be helpful for students, I'm sure.

Thank you for sharing some examples with clauses that don't use the article "the" (note that your last one is an example of a noun clause rather than an adjective clause). I tend to list English patterns as "rules" and "exceptions," but you could definitely call them something else in your classroom, such as "guidelines" or "common patterns," if you or your students start noticing too many exceptions. I've updated the sentence in the post to read "we usually need the article the..." so that it's clearer that there are exceptions.

Leave a Comment

Log In to Comment Reply

or
Comment Reply as a Guest
  • **bold**_italics_> quote

    This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

    Thinking of joining ESL Library?

    Complete this form to create an account and stay up to date on all the happenings here at ESL Library.